Rolex Batman Vs. Batgirl: Ultimate GMT-Master II Showdown

Rolex’s Batman and Batgirl watches are special versions of the GMT Master II watch, and they’re known for their unique black and blue colors on the bezel.

Both the Batman and Batgirl models exude a masculine and robust appearance with their distinct black and blue bezels. The primary difference lies in the bracelet: the Batman features an Oyster bracelet, known for its sturdy and commanding presence, while the Batgirl sports a Jubilee bracelet, which has more links, offering a slightly more refined look and enhanced comfort on the wrist.

Let’s take a closer look at each GMT Master Rolex models and help you decide which one is the perfect fit for you.

At a Glance: Rolex Batman vs Batgirl

Feature

Rolex Batman 116710BLNR

Rolex Batgirl 126710BLNR

Reference Number

116710BLNR

126710BLNR

Nickname

Batman

Batgirl

Case Size

40mm

40mm

Case Material

Stainless Steel (904L)

Stainless Steel (904L)

Bezel

Bidirectional, Black and Blue

Bidirectional, Black and Blue

Bracelet

Oyster Bracelet

Jubilee Bracelet

Movement

Calibre 3186

Calibre 3285

Power Reserve

Approximately 48 hours

Approximately 70 hours

Water Resistance

100 meters (330 feet)

100 meters (330 feet)

Launch Year

2013

2019

Discontinued

Yes (Replaced by Batgirl)

No

Distinguishing Features

Comes with an Oyster bracelet and is equipped with the older Caliber 3186 movement with a 48-hour power reserve

Features a Jubilee bracelet, which has more links and uses the newer Caliber 3285 movement, offering a longer 70-hour power reserve.



Price Range

S$18,194 – S$20,558

S$20,914 – S$23,023

The Rolex Batman and Batgirl models differ primarily in their bracelet designs. The Batman comes with a robust Oyster bracelet with broad, flat links that convey a sturdy and classic sportiness. In contrast, the Batgirl has a refined Jubilee bracelet, which features smaller, more intricate links, providing a sleeker and more sophisticated aesthetic.

The movement also varies; Batman uses the older Calibre 3186 with a 48-hour power reserve, whereas Batgirl is equipped with the newer Calibre 3285, providing a longer 70-hour power reserve and improved mechanics.

The Batman was introduced in 2013 and is now discontinued, making it a collector’s item, while the Batgirl, released in 2019, is still in production, more accessible and more expensive. 

History and Evolution 

The GMT-Master II series has a rich history that dates back to the early 1980s, with significant milestones marking its evolution.

Timeline of Rolex GMT Watches:

  • 1982: The GMT-Master II is introduced, enhancing the original GMT-Master with a new movement that allows for independent adjustment of the hour hand.
  • 1983: The “Pepsi” bezel, known for its red and blue colors, is launched in reference 16760.
  • 1989: The reference 16710 is introduced with a slimmer case design and the new caliber 3185 movement.
  • 2005: The “Cerachrom” bezel, a ceramic material resistant to scratches and fading, is introduced in the reference 116718LN.
  • 2007: The reference 116710LN is launched with a green 24-hour hand and a black Cerachrom bezel.
  • 2013: The “Batman” reference 116710BLNR makes its debut with a blue and black Cerachrom bezel, earning its nickname due to the dark and bold color scheme reminiscent of the comic book character.
  • 2018: The “Pepsi” reference 126710BLRO is introduced with the new generation movement, caliber 3285.
  • 2019: 
    • The “Batgirl” reference 126710BLNR is released with a Jubilee bracelet and the caliber 3285 movement. 
    • In the same year, the “Batman” reference 116710BLNR is discontinued, making way for the new Batgirl model.

The introduction of the Batman and Batgirl models marked significant milestones in the GMT-Master II series. 

Many Rolex models with GMT functionality, including the Batman and its counterpart, the Pepsi models—distinguished by their red and blue bezels—became icons of the Rolex GMT-Master II collection. Each model features a GMT hand, allowing for the tracking of a second time zone, and a date display neatly positioned at the date window, making these watches indispensable tools for global travelers.

Design and Aesthetics

The Rolex Batman (116710BLNR) has a 40mm Oystersteel case, a black dial with glowing markers, and a black and blue bezel that turns both ways. It features a flat sapphire crystal with a date magnifier and is water-resistant up to 100 meters.

close up image of Rolex GMT-Master II116710BLNR

On the other hand, the Rolex Batgirl (126710BLNR) also has a 40mm Oystersteel case and a black dial with glowing markers. It shares the black and blue bidirectional bezel and flat sapphire crystal with a date magnifier. The Batgirl is also water-resistant, up to 100 meters.

The key difference is that the Batman model has an Oyster bracelet and a strong three-link design. The Batgirl model first came out with a Jubilee bracelet, a five-link design with more fine links that is considered more elegant and “feminine” by watch enthusiasts. 

But since 2021, Rolex has let you choose either an Oyster or Jubilee bracelet for the GMT Master II steel models.

What’s Special About the Jubilee Bracelet

close up image of Jubilee bracelet

The inclusion of the Jubilee bracelet on Batgirl is a relatively recent development that has been well-received by Rolex enthusiasts and collectors alike. Here’s more about the Jubilee bracelet:

  • Material: Consistent with Rolex’s high standards, the Jubilee bracelet on the Batgirl is crafted from Oystersteel, a proprietary 904L stainless steel alloy with exceptional durability and a brilliant finish. This material is corrosion-resistant and maintains its beauty even in the harshest environments.
  • Design: The Jubilee bracelet for the Batgirl features its signature five-piece link design. This consists of three central links flanked by two larger links. The central links are polished, strikingly contrasting the brushed finish of the outer links. This combination of polished and brushed finishes adds depth and sophistication to the watch’s appearance.
  • Comfort: One of the Jubilee bracelet’s hallmarks is its comfort. With its smaller, more numerous links, the bracelet’s design allows for excellent flexibility and comfortably conforms to the wrist. This makes the Batgirl not only a visually stunning piece but also a pleasure to wear for extended periods.
  • Clasp: The bracelet is equipped with Rolex’s Oysterlock safety clasp, which prevents accidental opening. Additionally, it features the Easylink comfort extension link system, which is exclusive to Rolex. This innovative system allows the wearer to easily adjust the bracelet length by approximately 5 mm, enhancing comfort without needing tools.
  • Historical Significance: The Jubilee bracelet was originally introduced in 1945 to celebrate Rolex’s 40th anniversary. Its use on the GMT-Master II “Batgirl” adds a touch of historical reverence to a modern timepiece, bridging the gap between Rolex’s rich heritage and its contemporary innovations.
  • Visual Appeal: The combination of the GMT-Master II with a Jubilee bracelet was initially seen on the “Pepsi” reference 126710BLRO, and the extension of this design choice to the “Batgirl” has been celebrated for adding a level of sophistication and a slightly more formal aesthetic compared to the more utilitarian look of the Oyster bracelet. 

Technical Specifications

Caliber 3186 vs 3285

The Rolex Batman features the Caliber 3186, a significant technological advancement for the brand, with the Parachrom hairspring enhancing resistance to shocks and magnetic fields. This movement highlights Rolex’s focus on durability and reliability in challenging conditions.

The Batgirl model introduces the Caliber 3285, marking Rolex’s commitment to improving watch movement technology. The Chronergy escapement in this caliber increases energy efficiency and precision, showcasing a progressive approach to mechanical watch innovation.

A notable difference between the two models is the power reserve. The Batman offers approximately 48 hours, while the Batgirl extends this to 70 hours. This increase is particularly beneficial for those who frequently switch between different watches, as it reduces the need for winding.

Both models surpass the COSC standards for chronometers, maintaining an accuracy of -2/+2 seconds per day. However, the Batgirl’s Caliber 3285, with its enhanced Chronergy escapement, may provide even better long-term reliability and stability, especially in varied conditions.

Regarding resistance to environmental factors, both movements are robust, but the advancements in the Caliber 3285 might give the Batgirl an edge in more extreme conditions, such as higher magnetic fields or intense physical activities.

Market Trends and Pricing

Both the Batman and Batgirl models have experienced significant appreciation in value over time. As of January 2020, the retail price for the Batman was approximately S$12,600, and its market price has since increased to S$19,367 as of March 2024. Similarly, the Batgirl, with a retail price of S$15,700 as of January 2024, has seen its market price rise to S$21,953.

According to WatchCharts, both watches are considered medium-risk investments. The Batman has a risk score of 45, and the Batgirl has a slightly lower risk score of 40, indicating it might be a safer investment.

The Batgirl seems to have an edge in terms of investment potential, with higher value retention, larger sales volume, and a lower risk score compared to the Batman.

The Batman is still a good option for long-term investment, especially since its discontinuation could increase its value in the future.

The Batman Rolex watch can be considered a good investment if you’re looking for long-term growth, although it may not be as strong as other models in the short term. As for availability, the Rolex Batman might be harder to get since it has been discontinued, which could potentially increase its value in the future.

Rolex GMT Master II Owners Reviews

In Ariel Adams’ review on A Blog to Watch, the Rolex “Batman” model is lauded for its blue and black “Cerachrom” bezel, a first in steel Rolex watches, and its durable Oyster bracelet. The “Batgirl” stands out for its new Caliber 3285 movement, which enhances performance, and its Jubilee bracelet, which combines aesthetic appeal with comfort, making it great for travelers.

In the Fifth Wrist review by sgtudorboy1988, both models were praised for their exceptional craftsmanship, functionality, and aesthetic appeal. The review distinguishes the Batgirl for its Jubilee bracelet and updated movement as key features that set it apart, emphasizing these elements as significant upgrades that contribute to the model’s desirability and functionality.

So Which is Better?

Choosing between these two GMT Master II models depends on your specific design, comfort, and functionality preferences.

Choose the “Batman” if you value:

  • A classic and sporty look with the robust and durable Batman’s Oyster bracelet.
  • The iconic blue and black “Cerachrom” bezel for a distinctive aesthetic.
  • A preference for the traditional Rolex design that prioritizes durability and a more utilitarian style.

Choose the “Batgirl” if you prefer:

  • The latest advancements in Rolex technology include the upgraded Caliber 3285 movement, which offers improved energy efficiency and a longer power reserve.
  • A combination of aesthetic appeal and comfort with the Jubilee bracelet provides a slightly more formal or versatile look than the Oyster bracelet.
  • A watch that is particularly well-suited for travelers, thanks to its comfortable wear over long periods and practical GMT function.

Final Word

As iconic watches in the watch community, Batman and Batgirl’s distinct qualities and histories continue to make them sought-after and cherished favorites.

Key Takeaways

  • Batman is best for those who prefer a robust and classic design, collectors looking for historical significance, and individuals seeking a durable daily wear watch.
  • Batgirl is best for wearers who prioritize comfort, especially in warmer climates, and those who appreciate a more refined and elegant look.
  • Both the Rolex Batman and Batgirl models are appreciated in the Rolex community, but the Batgirl is slightly more popular and holds its value better, making it a potentially better investment.

Discover your perfect match from our extensive collection, from GMT Master II Watch Batman and Batgirl, among other exquisite Rolex watch models. Explore our collection, or stop by our boutique today!

Share the knowledge: